Okay I know it is technically not midseason. Even though it isn’t midseason I decided to review the season since sadly there is no Packer game to watch today. While things haven’t been perfect so far, I think the rest of the season looks pretty bright. The Packers started the season off pretty good and then hit a snag. The Packers have rebounded though and have gone on a two game winning streak.
Quarterback
Aaron Rodgers-Aaron Rodgers has shown why McCarthy had so much confidence in him starting. I am not going to get into a debate whether we would be better off with Favre since we will never know and I don’t really see the point debating. I will give Rodgers the credit he deserves. While he might not be as flashy as Favre he has been a great game manager. Rodgers rarely makes mistakes which is a huge plus for this team. He has also shown that he has toughness since he has played the last 3 games with a shoulder injury and has yet had great games in all three games. I believe the Packers just achieved something that is very rare in the NFL. They have successfully transitioned from a QB legend to another great QB. A
Matt Flynn and Brian Brohm-Neither have really been able to play and that is a good thing. Both have shown that they are rookie quarterbacks. At this point I wouldn’t trust either if they had to step in for a game. While I don’t have trust in them right now I do have faith that they will continue to grow (Rodgers was pretty bad in his first season as well) and at least one of them will be a good NFL QB. D
Running Back
Ryan Grant-So far this season Ryan Grant has been a disappointment. After missing all of training camp with his holdout and injury, Ryan Grant has not had a great season so far. He is just not playing up to his potential. Hopefully he is just having a hard time getting back into playing shape and in sync with his blockers. Otherwise I fear that he was a one year fluke. I am going to give Grant the benefit of the doubt especially since the running game has improved every game. Hopefully after the bye we can get back to how we ran the ball last season. C+
Brandon Jackson-I have actually been pretty impressed with Jackson this season. The problem is that the Packers rarely use him. Jackson has shown he has a motor and will fight for every extra yard. Since Grant has been back he has been rarely given the ball though. The Packers really need to give Jackson some more carries in order to give Grant so rest and also give the opposing defense a change of pace from the RB position. C+
Fullback
Korey Hall-I actually thought switching Korey Hall from a linebacker to a fullback was a gimic when we drafted Korey Hall. I didn’t think a linebacker could become a fullback but I was wrong. I actually think Korey Hall is one of the most underrated fullbacks in the league. Hall has already become a good blocker and he has also helped with a couple catches out of the backfield. A testament to Korey Hall is that the running game started getting better as soon as he returned from injury. B
Wide Receiver
Greg Jennings-After last years breakout season I had high expectations for Greg Jennings this season. Greg Jennings has met and surpassed every single one of my expectations. While Greg Jennings might not get as much credit as your TO’s, there is not a receiver in this league that I would want over Jennings. This decision is based on his play on the field and also his attitude off the field. Unlike most elite receivers, Jennings isn’t a selfish jerk. I don’t think we will ever have to worry about him becomming a locker room distraction. If Greg Jennings somehow doesn’t make the Pro Bowl it will be a travesty. A+
Donald Driver-While his numbers are down a little this season, Driver has proved to be as reliable as ever. Driver is never afraid to take the big hit in order to make the catch. He moves the chains and actually has twice as many touchdowns this season as he did all last season. Driver’s drop in stats isn’t due to a drop off in play but the fact that Greg Jennings has surpassed him as the go to receiver. I think Donald Driver has a couple more good years left under his belt. A-
Jordy Nelson-Like most people during the draft I wondered if the Packers really needed another receiver. It turns out that the Packers actually did. With Ruvell Martin and James Jones battling injuries the whole season Jordy Nelson has had the opportunity to step up. While he hasn’t been amazing I think he has already shown that he could be a very good pocession receiver. I think Jordy Nelson has a bright future ahead of him. B
Ruvell Martin and James Jones-I don’t know if it is just me but I have been really disappointed by both of them. Neither have stayed healthy this season. Hopefully the bye week will finally let both of them get healthy so the five receiver set can finally make it’s debut. Our passing offense has been dominant this season. Just imagine what we can do when we get Martin and Jones back at 100%. C-
Tight End
Donald Lee-While his stats might not say it, I think Donald Lee is one of the better TE’s in the league. Lee’s problem is that we have so many weapons on offense that it is hard for him to get the ball. While he doesn’t get a lot of opportunities, he does step up when his number is called. B+
Tory Humphrey-So far this season Tory Humphrey has shown what he always has. He makes some greats plays and then is silent the rest of the time. Humphrey needs to develop more consistentcy if he wants to be anything more than a backup the rest of his career. C
Jermichael Finley-I have actually been pretty disappointed with Jermichael Finley so far this season. While I knew he was going to be a project, I never thought he would be this big of project. I think Finley will be fine and eventually could be a great TE but he needs time to develop. He is just not at the right level of play to contribute much at this point in time. C-
Offensive Line
Since I am far from an offensive line guru I will address the offensive line as a unit. At this point it is probably the weakest or second weakest unit on the team. I don’t know if it is just me but I wouldn’t mind if Thompson spent half of next years draft on the offensive line. I think the Packers have to also thin about switching their blocking scheme. The zone scheme is just not working. The pass blocking has improved the last couple of weeks but the run blocking is improving way too slowly. Tauscher and Clifton are also getting older and I doubt either have a lot of playing time left. This offseason Thompson has his work cut out for him regarding the offensive line. C-
Defensive Ends
Aaron Kampman-Aaron Kampman has had a pretty good season so far. I think he would be even having a better season if he actually got more help from the other defensive end. Kampman is being singled out since teams aren’t afraid of our other defensive ends. Despite this Kampman is still having a good season and if he picks up his a play a little more down the stretch I think he will make the Pro Bowl once again. B+
Cullen Jenkins-Of all the injuries this season, I think Cullen Jenkins’ might be the worst for the team. Jenkins was having a very good season and was showing the potential the Packers saw when they extended him. He also helped out the defensive tackle position which could use all the help it could get. Too bad Jenkinsis out for the rest of the season since I would not nearly be as worried about the defensive line if we still had him. B
KGB-KGB has fallen off the deep end this season. KGB is only a rotational player and yet he has essentially done nothing in the little time he does play. I think KGB’s playing days are coming to an end very soon. One thing I know for sure is that KGB’s current contract will be gone after this season. There is no way in the world that the Packers should be playing KGB the most money on the team when he has done next to nothing this season. KGB will either be cut or will have to renogotiate his contract this offseason. D
Jeremy Thompson-Maybe it is just me but I think Thompson has a bright future with the team. Thompson has stepped in the last couple of weeks and I personally have been impressed with his play. While he makes some rookie mistakes, you can’t deny that he has talent and potential at the DE position. I think with more playing time this season, he could become a good DE for us next season. B-
Michael Montgommery-Michael Montgommery has pretty much been his normal self this year. He is a career backup. He will rarely make big plays but he also won’t give up many big plays. He is a solid DE and that’s it. C
Defensive Tackle
Ryan Pickett-Ryan Pickett has had a decent year but has kindof been a disappointment so far this season. He is just not playing as well as he did last season. I think there could be two things leading to worse play this season. First he might not yet be in playing shape. I don’t think this should be still affecting him but he did essentially miss every single training camp practice. The other explanation could be that he is forced to play more since there is only three DTs. Hopefully Pickett’s performance will pick up in the second half of the season. B-
Johnny Jolly-I think Jolly has had an on and off season. He has made some big plays this season but he has also become totally invisible at other points. Hopefully Jolly can play more consistently the rest of the season. B-
Colin Cole-I have actually been pretty impressed with Cole this season. I always thought of Cole as a pretty good rotational player and that was it. Cole has actually stepped up this season and has shown that he could be a pretty good defensive tackle. Obviously he hasn’t been dominated but I think his play has warranted more playing time in the future. B-
Justin Harrell-After the bye week Justin Harrell should finally be back. While a lot of people might think I am crazy, I think Justin Harrell’s return could be huge for the Packers defense. This is as long as he stays healthy. So why do I think Harrell could be a big addition to the defense. First he will be able to take some of the workload so our defensive line isn’t so tired at the end of games. Second if you actually look past his injury problems you will see that he actually played quite well last season when he actually got to play. He was pretty good in run support which the team really needs. I think Justin Harrell could be the piece to fix our struggling run defense.
Linebackers
Nick Barnett-Nick Barnett has had a disappointing season so far. I don’t know what it is be he is just not playing like he did last season. He is missing tackles and is not making the big plays that he has in the past. I think part of his problems can be attributed to the defensive line struggles since he does rely on the defensive line playing well. Hopefully the bye week will snap Nick Barnett back into his normal high level of play. B-
AJ Hawk-It is pretty hard to judge AJ Hawk’s season so far since he has been hampered with injuries the whole season. When he hasn’t been hurt he has played pretty well. You can tell the injuries are hampering his play though. Hopefully after the bye he will finally be healthy so he is able to return to his high level of play. B
Brady Poppinga and Brandon Chillar-Since they are essentially sharing the starting job now I have decided to review them together. Brady Poppinga has been a little silent this season but that might be partially due to him not having as much playing time. Chillar has actually been kindof a surprise. I actually expected him to just be a backup but he has actually stepped in and has shown to be pretty good in coverage. Hopefully this tandem will continue to work. B
Cornerbacks
Charles Woodson-I would seriously consider Charles Woodson to be the team MVP so far this season. Charles WOodson has shown why he is one if not the best cornerback in the league. He only is tied for the league lead in INTs and has only given up a couple completions all season. While you might not like Thompson, you must admit that he made a great signing when he signed Charles Woodson. A+
Al Harris-It’s hard to judge Al Harris’ season so far especially since he has missed most of the season. He was having a pretty good season before he was injured though. I still can’t believe that Al Harris will be able to return after the bye. I thought we had lost him for the rest of the season. I think the Packers should bring him back slowly though. Tramon has played very well in his absence so I don’t know why we shouldn’t bring Al Harris back slowly. B+
Tramon WIlliams-As already mentioned I think Tramon Williams has played very well this season. I think we have found one of our future starters at CB. While he had some troubles against the Cowboys, he has essentially been perfect since. While Williams will return to his 3rd CB spot, I think there is actually a pretty good chance that he could be a starter next season. A-
Will Blackmon and Pat Lee-Both of these players have shown some good and bad things this season. At this point both are more of projects. I think at least one of them could be a future starter for the Packers. I honestly don’t think the Packers could complain having players of Blackmon’s and Lee’s talent as 4th and 5th CBs. B
Jarrett Bush-Hopefully he won’t be on the roster much longer since he can’t cover and he hasn’t been that great in special teams either. F
Safeties
Nick Collins-I have been a critic of Collins in the past but I honestly can’t complain about much this season. Nick Collins has finally turned the corner and has become a playmaker. This is deffinently Nick Collins’ breakout season. If Nick Collins isn’t a Pro Bowler this season I will be very disappointed since Nick Collins is playing as well as any other safety in the league. A
Atari Bigby-Bigby has pretty much been hurt the whole season so I am not able to give him a grade. I do think he will have a big impact when he is finally able to return. If Bigby can return to his play of last year I think the Packers will have one of the best safety tandems in the league.
Aaron Rouse-Aaron Rouse’s season has been up and down so far this season. He has made some plays but he has also blown some coverages. When Bigby returns, Rouse will return to the bench which is the right thing in my opinion. Rouse needs some more time in order to develop. If he continues to develop the Packers will definently have a conundrum since they could have three starting caliber safeties. B
Kicker
Mason Crosby-While Mason Crosby has missed two field goals this season, I think he is still one of the best kickers in the league. A-
Punter
Derrick Frost-While he has been far from good, at this point I don’t think we will find a better punter. I think the Packers need to address the position in the offseason, hopefully through the draft. C
So what are your thoughts on the season so far? Who has really stepped up this season and who do you think has been a disappointment?